Clone SSH: git@github.com:shane-reaume/e2e-js-demo.git

        

Clone HTTPS: https://github.com/shane-reaume/e2e-js-demo.git

        

In the ever-evolving landscape of web development, ensuring that your website functions flawlessly across different browsers and devices is paramount. End-to-end (E2E) testing frameworks have become indispensable tools for developers aiming to deliver seamless user experiences. This year, I've started the process of evaluating leading open-source E2E testing frameworks to help you choose the one that best fits your project's needs. Our analysis considers reliability, modern features, flexibility (including API testing and custom integrations), ease of setup and use, and popularity metrics such as mentions, downloads, and search trends.

Hopefully, this will help you and your team decide on the best framework for your project. I plan to continue down this path, creating more in-depth blog posts on these frameworks. For now, we will stick with a high-level understanding, which will hopefully help learn about frameworks you may not have previously explored.

The Rise of End-to-End Testing Frameworks: A Historical Timeline

Selenium WebDriver: Released in 2006

Selenium WebDriver was introduced as part of Selenium 2.0 in 2006. It provided a more robust and object-oriented API compared to its predecessor, Selenium Remote Control (RC), and became a foundational tool for browser automation and testing.

Selenium was originally created by Jason Huggins at ThoughtWorks in 2004, then later Simon Stewart developed WebDriver at Google in 2006, which later merged with Selenium to become Selenium WebDriver in 2008.

Mozilla also contributed to the development of WebDriver implementations for Firefox.

PhantomJS: Released in 2011

PhantomJS is a headless WebKit scriptable with a JavaScript API. It allows for headless website testing, accessing web pages, and automating tasks without a browser UI.

PhantomJS was widely used for testing and automation before headless Chrome was available. Development was suspended in 2018, and it's no longer recommended for new projects.

CasperJS: Released in 2011

CasperJS is an open-source navigation scripting and testing utility written in JavaScript for PhantomJS (headless WebKit) and SlimerJS (headless Gecko). It provides high-level functions and methods to perform tasks such as navigation, clicking links, filling forms, and capturing screenshots.

Before headless Chrome and modern tools like Puppeteer, CasperJS was used for automating web page interactions and testing. Its reliance on PhantomJS, which is no longer maintained, has led to decreased usage.

Protractor: Released in 2013

Protractor was developed by Google in 2013 for testing AngularJS applications. It is built on top of WebDriverJS (the JavaScript implementation of Selenium WebDriver) and integrates seamlessly with AngularJS by understanding its internal events and architecture.

Protractor became a popular choice for end-to-end testing in Angular applications due to its ability to handle Angular-specific elements and asynchronous operations. However, as of 2021, Protractor has been deprecated, and the Angular team recommends migrating to other solutions like Cypress or Playwright.

WebdriverIO: Released in 2014

WebdriverIO is a modern, open-source automation test framework for Node.js. It uses Selenium WebDriver under the hood but provides a simplified and developer-friendly API. It supports both synchronous and asynchronous commands and has a rich plugin system.

WebdriverIO gained popularity for its flexibility and support for various testing frameworks like Mocha, Jasmine, and Cucumber. It also supports mobile app testing with Appium.

NightwatchJS: Released in 2014

NightwatchJS was first released in 2014. It was one of the earlier Node.js-based end-to-end testing frameworks built on top of Selenium WebDriver, offering a simple syntax and integrated testing solution for JavaScript developers.

NightwatchJS was initially developed by Pineview.io, a software consultancy focused on Node.js applications, but as an open-source project, NightwatchJS has received contributions from developers around the world.

Cypress: Released in 2015

Cypress was initially released in 2015. It gained popularity for its modern approach to end-to-end testing and developer-friendly features, such as time-travel debugging and automatic waiting.

TestCafe: Released in 2016 (Open-Source Version)

While the proprietary version of TestCafe was available earlier, the open-source version rewritten in Node.js was released by DevExpress in 2016. This version eliminated the need for browser plugins and WebDriver, simplifying the testing setup.

Puppeteer: Released in 2017

Puppeteer was released by Google's Chrome DevTools team in 2017. It is a Node.js library that provides a high-level API to control headless Chrome or Chromium over the DevTools Protocol.

Playwright: Released in 2020

Playwright was released by Microsoft in 2020. Developed by the team that previously worked on Puppeteer ( Google and Microsoft Engineers ), Playwright extends the concept by adding cross-browser support and additional features, making it a powerful tool for modern web application testing.

Historical Context and Evolution Summary:

Selenium WebDriver laid the groundwork for browser automation and influenced many subsequent frameworks. Before headless Chrome and modern tools like Puppeteer emerged, PhantomJS and CasperJS were instrumental in advancing browser automation.

The introduction of Puppeteer and Playwright marked a shift toward more developer-friendly APIs and the use of the DevTools Protocol. Similarly, Cypress and TestCafe offer all-in-one solutions that don't rely on Selenium WebDriver, simplifying setup and configuration.

The move toward frameworks like Playwright reflects a need for cross-browser testing capabilities and better handling of modern web application complexities.

Top 5 Winners

Playwright

• Rank: #1
• Award: Best at Cross-Browser Testing with Modern Features

npm install playwright
npm install @playwright/test --save-dev

        

const { test, expect } = require('@playwright/test');
test('Validate framework article title', async ({ page }) => {
  // Navigate to the website
  await page.goto('https://shaneofalltrades.com');
  // Click the specified link
  await page.click('text=The Top 5 Open-Source End-to-End Testing Frameworks of 2024');
  // Wait for navigation
  await page.waitForLoadState('networkidle');
  // Select the header element
  const header = await page.locator('#post-top-5-web-testing-frameworks-2024 > div > header > h2');
  // Assert the header contains the expected text
  await expect(header).toHaveText('The Top 5 Open-Source End-to-End Testing Frameworks of 2024');
});

        

{
  "scripts": {
    "test:playwright": "playwright test tests-pw/playwright.test.js"
  }
}

        

npm run test:playwright

        

Overview

Developed by Microsoft, Playwright is a powerful end-to-end (E2E) testing framework created by a team that includes former contributors to Google's Puppeteer project. Building upon the foundation laid by Puppeteer, Playwright extends its capabilities to support multiple browsers—including Chromium, Firefox, and WebKit—through a single API. It also supports multiple programming languages like JavaScript, TypeScript, Python, Java, and .NET, making it accessible to a broad range of developers.

One of Playwright's most significant advantages is its automatic waiting mechanism. This feature enhances test reliability by preventing flaky tests and eliminates the need to manually add timeouts or waits, resulting in faster test execution times. These improvements address common issues that were prevalent in older frameworks. If you've been doing E2E testing for a while, you're likely familiar with the headaches caused by flaky tests—Playwright effectively mitigates these issues, making it a standout choice for modern web application testing.

Features and Benefits

• Cross-Browser Support: Playwright can automate Chromium, Firefox, and WebKit browsers with a single API.
• Multi-Language Support: Write tests in your preferred language.
• Modern Testing Capabilities: Includes features like network mocking, geolocation, and permissions testing.
• Parallel Test Execution: Speeds up testing by running tests concurrently.
• API Testing and Custom Integrations: Offers robust API testing capabilities and integrates well with CI/CD pipelines.
• Mobile Device Emulation & Responsive Testing: Playwright can emulate mobile devices by simulating screen sizes, geolocation, and user agents.
• Network Control: Useful for mocking API calls, testing offline scenarios, or simulating network conditions like latency and bandwidth throttling.
• Code Generation (Codegen): Offers a code generation tool that records your actions in the browser and generates corresponding test scripts.
• Screenshot and Video Recording: Capture screenshots and record videos during test execution to help diagnose failures.
• Multi-Page and Frame Support: Efficiently manages multiple pages and iframes, allowing you to interact with different contexts within the same test.
• Headless and Headful Execution: Run your tests in headless mode for speed or in headful mode to visually observe test execution.
• Cross-Platform Support: Runs on Windows, macOS, and Linux, and supports testing on local machines, CI environments, and cloud services.

Ease of Use

Setting up Playwright is straightforward, thanks to comprehensive documentation and a supportive community. Its modern architecture reduces flakiness, making tests more reliable after setup. With a rick API, Playwright provides an extensive set of inputs, navigation, dialogs, and more, giving you fine-grained control over browser automation.

Popularity

Playwright has seen a surge in popularity, with increasing mentions in developer communities and a growing number of downloads.

• Website: https://playwright.dev
• Documentation: https://playwright.dev/docs/intro
• Repository: https://github.com/microsoft/playwright

Cypress

• Rank: #2
• Award: Best at Developer Experience for Modern Web Applications

const { defineConfig } = require("cypress");
module.exports = defineConfig({
  e2e: {
    specPattern: "cypress/integration/**/*.js",
    setupNodeEvents(on, config) {
      // implement node event listeners here
    },
  },
});

        

{
  "compilerOptions": {
    "strict": true,
    "baseUrl": "./",
    "paths": {}
  },
  "include": ["**/*"],
  "exclude": ["node_modules"]
}

        

npm install cypress --save-dev

        

describe('Validate Frameworks Article Title', () => {
  it('should navigate and validate the article title', () => {
    // Visit the website
    cy.visit('https://shaneofalltrades.com');
    // Click the specified link by its text
    cy.contains('a', 'The Top 5 Open-Source End-to-End Testing Frameworks of 2024').click();
    // URL should include the link's href
    cy.url().should('include', '/2024/11/21/top-5-web-testing-frameworks-2024/');
    // Validate the header text
    cy.get('#post-top-5-web-testing-frameworks-2024 > div > header > h2')
      .should('have.text', 'The Top 5 Open-Source End-to-End Testing Frameworks of 2024');
  });
});

        

npx cypress open

        

Overview

Cypress is a JavaScript-based E2E testing framework designed for modern web applications, with Cypress App being the open source version. It operates directly in the browser, with an interactive test runner, a GUI that allows developers to see tests execute in real-time, inspect elements, and debug seamlessly-- offering a unique and developer-friendly testing experience. Just like Playwright, Cypress offers extensive detailed documentation that aids in quick onboarding and troubleshooting.

Features and Benefits

• Real-Time Reloads and Time-Travel Debugging: Enhances developer productivity with snapshot capturing.
• Automatic Waiting: No need for explicit waits or sleeps in your tests.
• API Testing Capabilities: Built-in support for network requests.
• Rich Documentation and Community Support: Extensive resources for learning and troubleshooting.
• Stubbing and Spying: Easily control, stub, and test edge cases without relying on external servers. You can intercept and modify network requests and responses.
• Visual Interface: Test Runner provides an interactive UI where you can see commands execute in real-time, inspect elements, and debug more effectively.
• Easy Debugging: provides detailed error messages and stack traces, making it easier to identify and fix issues.
• Native Support for JavaScript Frameworks: Cypress works well with popular front-end frameworks like React, Vue, and Angular.

Ease of Use

Cypress is renowned for its simple setup process and intuitive interface. Tests are easy to write and maintain, thanks to its clear syntax and thorough and well-organized documentation, along with a vibrant community that contributes plugins, examples, and support. Also with Cross-Platform Support, Cypress runs on Windows, macOS, and Linux, making it accessible to developers regardless of their operating system.

Popularity

With a strong and active community, Cypress enjoys high popularity, evident from its significant number of downloads and GitHub stars. Also similar to Playwright, it has Built-In Assertions and Mocking, making it an all in one solution with no need for additional libraries like Mocha or Chai.

• Website: https://www.cypress.io
• Documentation: https://docs.cypress.io/
• Repository: https://github.com/cypress-io/cypress

Selenium WebDriver

• Rank: #3
• Award: Best at Language Support and Community Resources

npm install selenium-webdriver
npm install chromedriver --save-dev

        

const { Builder, By, until } = require('selenium-webdriver');
const assert = require('assert');
(async function validateArticleTitle() {
  // Initialize the WebDriver (using Chrome in this example)
  let driver = await new Builder().forBrowser('chrome').build();
  try {
    // Navigate to the website
    await driver.get('https://shaneofalltrades.com');
    // Locate the link by its text and click it
    const link = await driver.findElement(By.linkText('The Top 5 Open-Source End-to-End Testing Frameworks of 2024'));
    await link.click();
    // Wait until the header is located
    const headerLocator = By.css('#post-top-5-web-testing-frameworks-2024 > div > header > h2');
    await driver.wait(until.elementLocated(headerLocator), 10000);
    // Get the header text
    const header = await driver.findElement(headerLocator).getText();
    // Assert the header text
    assert.strictEqual(header, 'The Top 5 Open-Source End-to-End Testing Frameworks of 2024');
    console.log('Test Passed: Header text is correct.');
  } catch (error) {
    console.error('Test Failed:', error);
  } finally {
    // Quit the driver
    await driver.quit();
  }
})();

        

node tests/selenium.test.js

        

Overview

As one of the oldest players in the field, Selenium WebDriver is a staple in E2E testing. It offers extensive language and browser support, making it a versatile choice for many projects.

Features and Benefits

• Broad Language Support: Works with Java, C#, Python, Ruby, and more.
• Extensive Browser Compatibility: Supports all major browsers.
• Large Ecosystem and Community: Abundant resources and third-party integrations.
• Mobile Testing Support: Via Appium integration.

Ease of Use

While Selenium is powerful, its setup can be more complex compared to newer frameworks. Managing WebDrivers and configuring environments require additional effort.

Popularity

Selenium remains widely used and is often the go-to framework for many seasoned QA engineers.

• Website: https://www.selenium.dev
• Documentation: https://www.selenium.dev/documentation/webdriver/
• Repository: https://github.com/SeleniumHQ/selenium

TestCafe

• Rank: #4
• Award: Best at Simplifying Setup Without External Dependencies

npm install testcafe --save-dev

        

import { Selector } from 'testcafe';
fixture `Validate Frameworks Article Title`
  .page `https://shaneofalltrades.com`;
test('Navigate and validate the article title', async t => {
  // Click the specified link by its text
  await t
    .click(Selector('a').withText('The Top 5 Open-Source End-to-End Testing Frameworks of 2024'))
    .expect(Selector('#post-top-5-web-testing-frameworks-2024 > div > header > h2').innerText)
    .eql('The Top 5 Open-Source End-to-End Testing Frameworks of 2024');
});

        

{
  "scripts": {
    "test:testcafe": "testcafe chrome tests-tc/testcafe.test.js"
  }
}

        

npm run test:testcafe

        

Overview

Developed by DevExpress, TestCafe is an all-in-one Node.js solution for E2E testing that doesn't require browser plugins or WebDriver.

Features and Benefits

• No WebDriver Dependency: Simplifies setup and reduces maintenance.
• JavaScript and TypeScript Support: Leverages modern language features.
• Cross-Browser Testing: Supports all modern browsers.
• Concurrent Test Execution: Improves testing speed.

Ease of Use

TestCafe offers an easy setup with minimal configuration. Its syntax is straightforward, making test scripts readable and maintainable.

Popularity

While not as widely adopted as Cypress or Playwright, TestCafe has a dedicated user base and continues to grow steadily.

• Website: https://testcafe.io/
• Documentation: https://testcafe.io/documentation/402635/guides/overview/getting-started
• Repository: https://github.com/DevExpress/testcafe

Puppeteer

• Rank: #5
• Award: Best at High-Performance Chrome Automation

npm install puppeteer

        

import puppeteer from 'puppeteer';
import { strict as assert } from 'assert';
// Launch the browser
const browser = await puppeteer.launch({ headless: false });
const page = await browser.newPage();
try {
  // Navigate to the website
  await page.goto('https://shaneofalltrades.com', { waitUntil: 'networkidle2' });
  // Click the specified link using the 'locator' API
  await page.locator('a[href="/2024/11/21/top-5-web-testing-frameworks-2024/"]').click();
  // Wait for navigation
  await page.waitForNavigation({ waitUntil: 'networkidle2' });
  // Wait for the header element to be visible
  const headerSelector = '#post-top-5-web-testing-frameworks-2024 > div > header > h2';
  await page.waitForSelector(headerSelector, { visible: true });
  // Get the header text using $eval(selector, pageFunction, args)
  const headerText = await page.$eval(headerSelector, el => el.textContent.trim());
  // Assert the header text
  assert.strictEqual(
    headerText,
    'The Top 5 Open-Source End-to-End Testing Frameworks of 2024'
  );
  console.log('Test Passed: Header text is correct.');
} catch (error) {
  console.error('Test Failed:', error);
} finally {
  // Close the browser
  await browser.close();
}

        

node tests-puptr/puppeteer.test.js

        

Overview

Puppeteer is a Node.js library by Google that provides a high-level API to control Chrome or Chromium over the DevTools Protocol.

Features and Benefits

• Headless Browser Automation: Ideal for automating tasks in Chrome.
• Performance Testing: Useful for measuring load times and performance metrics.
• Web Scraping and Data Extraction: Efficient for non-testing automation tasks.
• Straightforward API: Simple methods to interact with page elements.

Ease of Use

Puppeteer is easy to set up for projects focused on Chrome automation. However, its limited cross-browser support can be a drawback for comprehensive E2E testing.

Popularity

It's popular for specific use cases like web scraping and is well-maintained with regular updates.

• Website: https://pptr.dev/
• Documentation: https://pptr.dev/category/introduction
• Repository: https://github.com/puppeteer/puppeteer

NightwatchJS

• Rank: *Honorable Mention
• Award: Best at Integrating with Selenium WebDriver in JavaScript

npm install nightwatch --save-dev

        

npm install chromedriver --save-dev

        

// nightwatch.conf.js
module.exports = {
  src_folders: ['tests'],
  webdriver: {
    start_process: true,
    server_path: require('chromedriver').path,
    port: 9515
  },
  test_settings: {
    default: {
      desiredCapabilities: {
        browserName: 'chrome'
      }
    }
  }
};

        

module.exports = {
  'Validate Frameworks Article Title': function (browser) {
    browser
      .url('https://shaneofalltrades.com')
      .waitForElementVisible('body', 1000)
      // Click the specified link by its text
      .useXpath()
      .click("//a[text()='The Top 5 Open-Source End-to-End Testing Frameworks of 2024']")
      .useCss()
      // Wait for the header to be visible
      .waitForElementVisible('#post-top-5-web-testing-frameworks-2024 > div > header > h2', 1000)
      // Assert the header text
      .assert.containsText('#post-top-5-web-testing-frameworks-2024 > div > header > h2', 'The Top 5 Open-Source End-to-End Testing Frameworks of 2024')
      .end();
  }
};

        

{
  "scripts": {
    "test:nightwatch": "nightwatch --config nightwatch.conf.js"
  }
}

        

npm run test:nightwatch

        

Overview

NightwatchJS is a Node.js E2E testing framework built on Selenium WebDriver. It offers a simple syntax and integrated testing solution.

Why It Didn’t Make the Top 5

While NightwatchJS provides solid features and cross-browser support, it requires managing Selenium servers, which can complicate the setup. Its popularity has also waned compared to more modern frameworks like Cypress and Playwright.

• Website: https://nightwatchjs.org/
• Documentation: https://nightwatchjs.org/guide/overview/what-is-nightwatch.html
• Repository: https://github.com/nightwatchjs/

Best Overall: Playwright

After evaluating all the contenders, Playwright emerges as the best overall E2E testing framework this year. Its combination of modern features, reliability, cross-browser support, and multi-language capabilities makes it a robust choice for developers seeking a comprehensive testing solution.

Conclusion

Choosing the right E2E testing framework depends on your project's specific needs. If you're looking for modern features and cross-browser testing, Playwright is the way to go. For an excellent developer experience focused on modern web applications, Cypress is a strong contender. Selenium WebDriver remains a solid choice for projects requiring extensive language support and a mature ecosystem. If ease of setup without external dependencies is your priority, consider TestCafe. For specialized Chrome automation tasks, Puppeteer is unmatched.

Ultimately, the best framework is one that aligns with your testing requirements and integrates smoothly into your development workflow. Happy testing!